Skip to content

‘It Was Always You’: Tyler Hynes & Erin Krakow Star in New 2021 Hallmark Movie

  • by

Hallmark Channel is continuing its Love Ever After movie event with the premiere of It Was Always You starring Tyler Hynes and Erin Krakow. The movie has talented actors, a stunning backdrop, plus that heartwarming touch all fans seem to love about Hallmark films. We’ve got some details about the movie below, including plot, photos, and even a trailer. So, keep reading for all that info!

It Was Always You Plot + Cast

It Was Always You follows Elizabeth (Erin Krakow) as she finalizes her wedding. But, when a storm leaves her fiancé stranded on the other side of town, she’s panicking. Plus, she’s also stuck with her fiancé’s free-spirited brother, David (Tyler Hynes), which doesn’t exactly help matters. The two couldn’t be more opposite, but, as time goes on, she starts to get used to David’s influence. Could that make her question more of her life’s choices?

If you caught Hallmark’s Countdown to Christmas event this year, then you’ll remember Tyler Hynes from On the 12th Date of Christmas with Mallory Jansen. Other credits to his name include: Lifetime’s 2005 film Mom at Sixteen, as well as Hallmark’s It’s Christmas, Eve and Winter in Vail. He’s also guested on episodes of Flashpoint, Warehouse 13, and Heartland.

Erin Krakow is a known fixture of Hallmark, having held the lead role of Elizabeth Thatcher in When Calls the Heart since 2014. Since then, she’s starred in quite a few movies for the network, including the Father Christmas trilogy. Other works of hers include a recurring role on Army Wives, as well as guest spots on Castle and NCIS. Erin also studied drama at the esteemed Juilliard School in New York City.

Any other details?

Ahead of the weekend premiere, Hallmark Channel has released a sneak peek preview of It Was Always You. The 30 second trailer includes Erin and Tyler in character, and the preview clip features the duo enjoying dinner at a local bar. Check it out below:

Both Erin and Tyler and have posted numerous behind the scenes photos and videos. We’ve rounded up a few of our favorites, including some promotional photos, and a little bit of fun in-between takes.

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by 🎥🏴🔌📓 (@tyler_hynes)

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Erin Krakow (@erinkrakow)

Last, but certainly not least, we’ve got some photos to share from It Was Always You. Check out Erin, Tyler, and their co-stars in our gallery below:

Tune in to the premiere of It Was Always You on Feb. 27 at 9/8 c, only on Hallmark Channel.


Mix Up in the Mediterranean: Jeremy Jordan & Jessica Lowndes Star in 2021 Hallmark Movie

Valentine’s Again: Nicky Whelan & Greg Vaughan Star in 2021 Hallmark Film

Playing Cupid: Laura Vandervoort & Nicholas Gonzalez Star in 2021 Hallmark Movie